Free State Wyoming Forum

Wyoming Research and Information => General Wyoming Living Information => Topic started by: kingskid on May 29, 2012, 09:20:08 PM

Title: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: kingskid on May 29, 2012, 09:20:08 PM
Since I'll be doing some eating out, anyone have any favorite restaurants?

KK
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Mjolnir on May 29, 2012, 09:35:30 PM
I'm a huge fan of Isabella's in Newcastle.  It is an Italian restaurant that also does a little of everything else (specialization is for insects, right?).  They have excellent steak Friday night and big, beautiful burgers which are one of my favorites.

There are also off menu items like the Smokehouse Joe's pizza that are worth trying a slice of.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: kingskid on May 29, 2012, 09:57:55 PM
Quote
Mjoinir:  I'm a huge fan of Isabella's in Newcastle.  It is an Italian restaurant that also does a little of everything else (specialization is for insects, right?).  They have excellent steak Friday night and big, beautiful burgers which are one of my favorites.

O, Mama Mia, tutto gracie!  Although I usually prefer my own Italian cooking, when you're on the road, the locals know where to eat.

KK
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Cyclonesteve on May 29, 2012, 10:04:28 PM
Sadly, I have no taste.  :)

When I visited Newcastle I went to Pizza Hut & Taco John's! (Pizza Hut was good, TJ's OK)
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Cyclonesteve on May 29, 2012, 10:06:26 PM
Sadly, I have no taste.  :)

When I visited Newcastle I went to Pizza Hut & Taco John's! (Pizza Hut was good, TJ's OK)

I forgot to add, Subway in Sundance. I really liked the people there.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: kingskid on May 30, 2012, 08:02:14 AM
Okay, Steve, fast-food works when you're hungry! ;D
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Crappiewy on May 30, 2012, 09:18:25 AM
Its hard to reccomend a place in sundance. Other than subway there are only 3 places that are normally open. Aro, Etta's Place and a new hamburger place whose name I cand remember. All are over priced have mediocre food and bad service unless you are a local friend. There is also higbees when they decide to be open but that is hit and miss.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Kelly on May 30, 2012, 10:50:35 AM
I think Isabella's is for sale in Newcastle, so that may not be open by the time you arrive if it sells (big "IF" there).

Donna's Diner on Main St in Newcastle is ok for diner-quality breakfast; never had other meals there.

These counties are no place for 'fine dining' unless you cook it yourself.

Bon Appetit!
Kelly
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: kingskid on May 30, 2012, 10:34:47 PM
Thanks, all, for the heads up.  The motel I'll be staying at has a microwave and refrigerator, so will manage!

KK
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: manfromnevada on May 31, 2012, 09:03:59 AM
There's a small cafe in Hulett called "The Ponderosa". It's OK but they close up in the afternoon.

There's that "expensive" place in Buehla (?). Geez, I used to live there and now can't remember how to spell the name! Population 30.
It's a restaurant/bar. Can't miss it. Not cheap though. Good food.

Nothing to speak of in Moorcroft. One cafe I believe.

Small county. No traffic lights anywhere (Crook). Just the way I like it.

Mac
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: kingskid on May 31, 2012, 11:16:22 AM
Mac, I agree.  I would rather not have a lot of the conveniences more densely populated counties might provide in exchange for fewer people, traffic lights, etc.!  You just learn to cope with less and that makes you become more resourceful.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Vince on May 31, 2012, 02:19:26 PM
There's a small cafe in Hulett called "The Ponderosa". It's OK but they close up in the afternoon.

There's that "expensive" place in Buehla (?). Geez, I used to live there and now can't remember how to spell the name! Population 30.
It's a restaurant/bar. Can't miss it. Not cheap though. Good food.

Nothing to speak of in Moorcroft. One cafe I believe.

Small county. No traffic lights anywhere (Crook). Just the way I like it.

Mac

Mac,

We were in Hulett some years ago and ate right down the street from the hotel chain (newer hotel, lots of horns hangin' on the walls, damned if I can remember the name lol).

The owner told us he was from the Philly area.  Is that the ponderosa?  There is (or was) a hardware store right across the street.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: BAR BAR 2 on June 01, 2012, 04:35:11 PM
I like to stop at the ARO in Sundance whenever I'm hauling cows to St.Onge. Their chickenfried steak is pretty good. I've always had good service and did'nt find the prices bad at all.

Tex
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: manfromnevada on June 02, 2012, 07:41:58 AM


Mac,

We were in Hulett some years ago and ate right down the street from the hotel chain (newer hotel, lots of horns hangin' on the walls, damned if I can remember the name lol).

The owner told us he was from the Philly area.  Is that the ponderosa?  There is (or was) a hardware store right across the street.

Yes, that's the Ponderosa. A decent place. Has a bar in back. And they allow smoking too in the room with the bar. One of the last holdouts. Don't like smoking, but I'll defend their right to allow it in THEIR restaurant.

Mac
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Vince on June 02, 2012, 12:47:48 PM
Quote
Yes, that's the Ponderosa. A decent place. Has a bar in back. And they allow smoking too in the room with the bar. One of the last holdouts. Don't like smoking, but I'll defend their right to allow it in THEIR restaurant.

Mac

Thanks Mac, I thought it might be the Ponderosa but wasn't certain.  The hotel is the Best Western.

I agree about the smoking.  I like Neil Smith's take on it, I gave up smokes a long time ago for personal reasons but I style myself a political smoker.  I remain split on the aroma; a dead ashtray is foul smelling yet, not too long ago a youngster in my vicinity lit up.  He tapped a camel filter out of the pack, grabbed it with the edge of a tooth/lip combo, pulled out a classic zippo to light it!  That first drift of smoke combined with the smell of the lighter (burning fluid and flint) smelled way better than it should have  :D  But absolutely yes, it's your body to smoke with and it's his establishment to permit smoking.  As it should be.

At any rate, I agree with your assessment of the restaurant.  Decent place and food, nice folks who run it and serve you.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: NiteRider on June 02, 2012, 01:33:06 PM
I love the aroma of second-hand cigar and pipe smoke.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: mystica on June 02, 2012, 10:01:57 PM
I love the aroma of second-hand cigar and pipe smoke.

I'm glad I don't smoke and don't much like to be around it but I still remember with a smile my grandfather smoking his cigars with old world relish. They were a warm brown and looked like they were wrapped in leaves. He'd stub them out whenever he was done and do a manly, satisfied expression. To this day, when a faceless waft of cigar smoke comes my way it feels so familiar and rich with memories.

Just to stay on thread, thanks for all the restaurant info  ;)  I hope Isabella's is still there at the end of the month.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Mjolnir on June 02, 2012, 10:21:31 PM
  I hope Isabella's is still there at the end of the month.

It has been for sale for a long while, so I don't think it'll be changing hands any time soon.  And I feel there will be a riot if one of the town's finest establishments goes away.
Title: Re: Restaurant recommendations in Weston/Crook Counties
Post by: Foundit on June 02, 2012, 10:42:13 PM
The Aro Restaurant in Sundance.  The food and service are great.