I think a good analogy would be a hobbyist or special interest magazine. There will be readers who are just getting into the hobby and are looking for articles written for beginners. Readers with experience will want articles that cover new ways, tips, and tricks. The old timers will tend to get bored unless there is enough news or highly specialized articles.
How to keep everyone happy? That is a publisher's problem.
On forums, the old timers often hang out and help the beginners.
My feeling is that most of the "Wyoming Seekers" have found what they were looking for. The many who are/were not actively seeking, might still be interested if someone took the effort to "sell" it to them.
Speaking for myself, I am happy to help someone who is seeking, but I have better things to do than to "sell" an idea to people who don't or won't understand its benefits. I am glad to discuss a healthy diet, but if someone wants to cram their face with fast food, that's their choice, not my problem.
It could be that there are many people who are still interested, but are tied to a job. At the beginning, my hope was that some of us would bring or create businesses that would help others get started. But I haven't seen much of that. A couple times, I offered my programming and/or electronics experience to FSW members with their projects, but no takers. How sad is that?
I would recommend goldismoney2.com as a lively forum with discussions of money, politics, and everything else.